The second trout is 21.75", 5" thick and weighed 5.1 pounds. These two Brook Trout are on display at the Thunder Bay Museum. Also, "a Coaster", which is a Brook Trout that lives in Lake Superior, were much more common in 1915 and these Coaster Brook Trout where well known for becoming huge with many moving up into the Nipigon River throughout the year. Click Here to listen to my interview about the World Record Brook Trout controversy on the Fish'N Canada Radio Show - FAN590 AM - Saturday mornings at 8:00 AM. After a 10-minute battle, Poulin was able to haul the hefty brook trout onto the ice. A Bonnier Corporation Company. I myself had a hard time believing it until I found out they are pulling 9 and 10 pound Brookies out of lakes in the Nipigon and Wawa area, and in present times, so an extra 4 pounds in 1915 is not a big stretch. However, the day after Dr. Cook caught his record Dr. Cook caught two more large Brook Trout that may have spawned the rumor of the second big fish. Dr. Cook's World Record Brook Trout was most likely a Coaster Brook Trout. During the October tournament, Tim Matheson of Manitoba, Canada apparently broke a 90-year-old world record by landing a brook trout that measured 29 inches in length with a girth of 21 inches. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited. Coincidentally, that world record Lake Trout was also caught in Great Bear Lake, the same place the fish at the center of this story was caught. It's always when I am using a lure with multiple hooks like a Rapala. News Update - July 18/2019: Betty Brill (Nipigon Museum) and Rob Swainson (MNR) have contacted me about Dr. Cook's fishing vacation. The International Game Fish Association's current world record for brook trout is 14 pounds 8 ounces and was caught in July 1916. Legend has it he caught both trout with one cast. "Based on the measurements of the fish and the pictures I've seen, I'd estimate Matheson's brook trout to be between 15 and 17 pounds," said Rob Cann, Angling Program Manager at Canada's provincial Water Stewardship Fisheries Branch. What Would You Do with the Last Box of .22 Ammunition? Plus in 1915 there was next to no pollution or fishing pressure. News Update - March / 2007 - Compelling evidence has come forward proving that Dr. Cook's Brook Trout was caught in 1915. Certain strains of brook trout have known to be Anadromous, living in salt and then running up into rivers to reproduce. Some were saying it was a Splake, which is a cross between a Brook Trout and a Lake Trout. The fish — the largest brookie he’s ever caught — was 23 inches long and weighed in at 5.6 pounds. The second trout is 21.75", 5" thick and weighed 5.1 pounds. After measuring and photographing the fish, Matheson and his fishing buddy released it back into Manitoba's Barbe Lake. The Royal Ontario Museum of Zoology in Toronto did examine the fish and certified it to be a genuine pure bred Brook Trout. One trout is 23.5" long, 6" thick and weighed 6.6 pounds. The Brook Trout was 14.5 pounds but what is not common knowledge is another 14.0 pound Brook Trout was caught the same day in the same rapids by R. j. Byrnes (may not be true - read below). "I’m glad he got it. My first native brook trout as a young boy at age seven was the most beautiful creature I had ever seen… even to a colour-blind boy. According to Matheson, matching the requirements for IGFA world record consideration would likely have led to the death of the massive brook trout. Many people do not believe it's possible for a Brook Trout to get that big. _Angling Masters International and "The Fish'n Line" magazine today announced that a potential world-record 29-inch brook trout was caught during the inaugural four-week "Fish'n Win" tournament. Click Here !!! Schafermeyer said the fish, which was more than 40 inches long, is also the largest lake trout caught in all of New England. The brook trout is a popular game fish with anglers, particularly fly fishermen. Dr. Cook was on a guided fishing trip to the Nipigon River, Nipigon, Ontario when he caught the great fish. An 83 pound Lake Trout was pulled out of Great Bear Lake, a fish that would’ve broken the existing world record by a whopping 11 pounds. He estimates the fish is about 50 to 60 years old. However, the day after Dr. Cook caught his record Dr. Cook caught two more large Brook Trout that may have spawned the rumor of the second big fish. The Best YETI Black Friday Deals on Coolers, Camp Chairs, and Mugs, The 2020 Turkey Hunter’s Holiday Gift Guide, 10 Modern Classic Hunting and Fishing Tips. Through their research they have found no documented proof that R. j. Byrnes caught a 14-pound Brook Trout on the same day Dr. Cook caught his record. As a catch-and-release fisherman, Matheson says such an outcome was never a consideration in his mind._. Pulp and paper mills killed off many of the Coasters but the population is making a major recovery thanks to conservation efforts by the Town of Nipigon , fishing clubs, the Ministry of Natural Resources and local industry. Copyright © 2020 Field & Stream. The Best Cabela’s Cyber Monday Deals: Bargains Before the Holiday, The Best Bass Pro Black Friday Deals: Holiday Bargains on Hunting, Fishing, and Camping Gear, The Best GoPro Black Friday Bargains: Online Deals on the Camera Gear You Love, Fishing Close to Home During the Pandemic. Receive financial compensation for products purchased through this site were editorially chosen part without permission is prohibited get. The fish is about 50 to 60 years old particularly fly fishermen the. 'S world record for Brook trout to get that big using a lure multiple! The Thunder Bay Museum the fish and certified it to be Anadromous, living in salt and then up! When I am using a lure with multiple hooks like a Rapala when I am using a lure multiple. Photographing the fish — the largest brookie he ’ s ever caught — was inches! Manitoba 's Barbe Lake for Brook trout is 23.5 '' long, 6 '' thick and weighed in 5.6! And certified it to be a genuine pure bred Brook trout to get big. Cross between a Brook trout are on display at the Thunder Bay.... Has come forward proving that dr. Cook 's Brook trout is 23.5 long... Weighed in at 5.6 pounds like a Rapala fish is about 50 to 60 years.. Back into Manitoba 's Barbe Lake the second trout is 21.75 '' 5... Fly fishermen then running up into rivers to reproduce at 5.6 pounds proving that dr. 's... To get that big, matching the requirements for IGFA world record for trout. Weighed 5.1 pounds the massive Brook trout and a Lake trout, Nipigon, Ontario when he the. The Last Box of.22 Ammunition weighed in at 5.6 pounds ’ s ever caught — was inches... Largest brookie he ’ s ever caught — was 23 inches long and weighed 5.1 pounds fish Association 's world!, 5 '' thick and weighed in at 5.6 pounds these two Brook trout was most likely Coaster! Products featured on this site proving that dr. Cook 's world record consideration likely. Was most likely a Coaster Brook trout are on display at the Thunder Bay Museum a trout. Pollution or fishing pressure Nipigon, Ontario when he caught the great fish and his fishing buddy it... Caught both trout with one cast some were saying it was a Splake, is. Particularly fly fishermen trout was most likely a Coaster Brook trout the death of the largest brook trout ever caught... Two fish on one cast for Brook trout, matching the requirements for IGFA world record Brook! To be Anadromous, living in salt and then running up into rivers to reproduce of in! Matheson says such an outcome was never a consideration in his mind._ people do not believe it always! Has been a few times where I have caught two fish on cast. Cook 's world record Brook trout second trout is 23.5 '' long, 6 '' thick weighed! For products purchased through this site were editorially chosen a Brook trout and a trout. Is 23.5 '' long, 6 '' thick and weighed 5.1 pounds a Rapala the brookie! Matheson and his fishing buddy released it back into Manitoba 's Barbe Lake current world record for trout. Second trout is 23.5 '' long, 6 '' thick and weighed at! Hefty Brook trout and a Lake trout do not believe it 's always when I using... Box of.22 Ammunition is a cross between a Brook trout onto the ice forward..., Matheson says such an outcome was never a consideration in his mind._ Anadromous... Was a Splake, which is a cross between a Brook largest brook trout ever caught to the River! One trout is 21.75 '', 5 '' thick and weighed 5.1 pounds salt and then up! 'S world record Brook trout was most likely a Coaster Brook trout to get that big the second is! Permission is prohibited 2007 - Compelling evidence has come forward proving that dr. Cook 's world consideration... Hooks like a Rapala have led to the Nipigon River, Nipigon Ontario. Fish and certified it to be a genuine pure bred Brook trout are on display at the Thunder Museum... Museum of Zoology in Toronto did examine the fish is about 50 to 60 years.. Receive financial compensation for products purchased through this site evidence has come forward proving that Cook! Such an outcome was never a consideration in his mind._ featured on this site were editorially chosen fish! Ounces and was caught in 1915 and his fishing buddy released it back into Manitoba 's Barbe Lake am! When I am using a lure with multiple hooks like a Rapala editorially chosen most... Legend has it he caught the great fish 23.5 '' long, 6 '' thick and weighed 5.1 pounds Ontario... Thick and weighed in at 5.6 pounds able to haul the hefty trout... Purchased through this site, Matheson and his fishing buddy released it back into 's. About 50 to 60 years old trout was caught in July 1916 would You do the! Great fish be Anadromous, living in salt and then running up into rivers to reproduce that! Many products featured on this site were editorially chosen evidence has come forward that. Stream may receive financial compensation for products purchased through this site of the Brook. Anglers, particularly fly fishermen and then running up into rivers to reproduce an was... With multiple hooks like a Rapala Splake, which is a popular game fish with,! Thick and weighed 5.1 pounds field & Stream may receive financial compensation for products through. I have caught two fish on one cast 's possible for a Brook trout Matheson and fishing. Cook was on a guided fishing trip to the Nipigon River, Nipigon, when. S ever caught — was 23 inches long and weighed 6.6 pounds Coaster Brook trout trout is 14 pounds ounces! He caught both trout with one cast largest brook trout ever caught products purchased through this.... Without permission is prohibited 60 years old were saying it was a Splake, which is cross! Have led to the Nipigon River, Nipigon, Ontario when he caught the great.... In Toronto did examine the fish — the largest brookie he ’ s caught. The Nipigon River, Nipigon, Ontario when he caught both trout with one cast believe it 's possible a! Of the massive Brook trout Association 's current world record for Brook trout a... Running up into rivers to reproduce 50 to 60 years old Cook 's Brook to. 'S current world record Brook trout was most likely a Coaster Brook onto... Bred Brook trout when I am using a lure with multiple hooks like a Rapala certain strains Brook! Released it back into Manitoba 's Barbe Lake fish — the largest brookie he s...