The Alliance isn't helping him. Anderson quits the Council by the time ME3 happens if you choose him, and Udina takes his place. Choosing which person should be the first-ever human member of the Council is a big moment in the game, but it's hard to see what the long-term ramifications will be for either . Because f*** you that's why. font size decrease . The council isn't helping him. Udina comes across as a bit of a blowhard in the first and second Mass Effect games and doesn't trust or respect Shepard as Anderson does. If Udina is the human Councilor and the previous Council was left to perish, Shepard will be unable to regain Spectre status. That said, Anderson points out he's facing anti-human prejudice as well as an unsympathetic Council, and he does truly seem to care about the fate of the human race, especially once the Reapers arrive. . Politics play a major role in the Mass Effect universe. . . However, his desire the appease the Council frequently puts him at odds with . Anderson clearly isn't very happy in the Councilor role, and will quit and be replaced by Udina before the events of ME3. Its when you get more in the middle moralities that they get trickier. You can choose between Anderson and Udina, or you can let the Council make the choice for you. The Alliance isn't helping him. Depending on who survived a mission during Mass Effect 1, Udina . It only changes ME2 a tiny bit. I chose Anderson, because fuck Udina, dude's a toolbag. in the book "Retribution" Anderson quits, i forgot most of the specifics, but he ends up leaving his duties entirely, so no matter if you decide to make him a Councilor or not, the political BS is at a point that he . If you end up choosing the hardened politician in Ambassador Udina, he will end up hurting Shepard's efforts to prepare for the Reapers at every . Now Udina knows how it feels to be Shepard. The council isn't helping him. If you want to rejoin the Spectres in ME2 (mostly just a formality), choose Anderson. That said, Anderson points out he's facing anti-human prejudice as well as an unsympathetic Council, and he does truly seem to care about the fate of the human race, especially once the Reapers arrive. Here's a guide to both choices. These games don't just tell the tale of the terrifying Reaper . Written by Peter Szpytek .
There's a clear best choice. Imported the save to ME2 and everything's fine, Udina works for Anderson but is still a toolbag because he's just a . It does change some minor events for Mass Effect 2 though. Shepard also gets to nominate either Anderson, beloved space dad, or Udina, actual monster-person and human terrorist ally, to the Council as humanity's first representative. Mass Effect 1: How Should Anderson Free The Normandy? Anderson or Udina for Councilor - Citadel - Choices | Mass If Shepard nominated Udina, he becomes the first human Councilor, with Anderson as his assistant. You can choose between Anderson or Udina to head the new Council. Now in Mass Effect 3, Udina is the one who is isolated and is forced to fight the battle for Earth alone. Udina comes across as a bit of a blowhard in the first and second Mass Effect games and doesn't trust or respect Shepard as Anderson does. Anderson or Udina, which one is more likely paragorn Players can choose between Captain Anderson or Ambassador Udina, who become Chairman if the council is sacrificed, and Morality dictates either a full Human council or a multi-species council . Although you can still choose between Anderson and Udina to head the new council, only the former will reinstate your Spectre status in Mass Effect 2. In Mass Effect, Commander Shepard can appoint either Ambassador Udina or Captain Anderson to be the human Councilor. Honestly having a second option to kill the council with Udina in it would be glorious. A new council is formed in their stead; diverse if your morality spectrum was Paragon-focused, human-only if Renegade. Why the hell is Udina the canon choice?? - Page 2 Let's face it; nobody picked Ambassador Udina to be on the council over Captain Anderson. The Alliance would much rather have him in power than Andersan because Udina is 'very good' at playing Politics and isn't afraid to toss his morales aside if it serves in the best interest for humanity. Udina is a Natural Born Politician who knows how to get the things that he desires. Mass Effect 2 Consequences: The Council will grant you an audience and reinstate you as a Spectre as a sign of goodwill. mass effect 3 - Why is Anderson not a councilor? - Arqade Why would anyone pick Udina over Anderson as the Councilor The choice between Anderson and Udina is a big one in Mass Effect 1 because Shepard will need all the help they can get against the reapers. Should Anderson be nominated for the Council, Udina becomes his personal adviser instead. Mass Effect 2. I don't mean to be rude to Udina, but Anderson is Shepard's former CO, meaning the player has spent more time . Only Anderson will offer to reinstate your Spectre status in Mass Effect 2; Udina will not. 2010 8:23 am #5716008. There's a clear best choice. By default, Cerberus became the only way to save Earth, so Udina took the option. . And the comic takes place around a year after Mass Effect 2 (and after Anderson stepped down from his position) Edited by mrsph, 18 November 2010 - 02:21 AM. Donnel Udina is a minor antagonist in the Mass Effect trilogy. This is when Mass Effect really shows its roots as a silly space opera, Anderson as councilor is like putting Jesse Ventura secretary-general of the UN. If Anderson is selected, he'll only serve on the Council in Mass Effect 2. If Udina is picked as the Human representative, and you saved the Council in Mass Effect 1, Udina can give you your Spectre status back in Mass Effect 2. In Mass Effect 2, Udina will prove considerably more acrimonious to Shepard than Anderson, although you'll frankly have little interaction with the Council either way. In the novel Mass Effect: Retribution, Anderson hands over the political negotiations he was in charge of to Udina in order to assist Kahlee Sanders from the Grissom Academy with locating Paul Grayson.. Nevertheless, the show must go on. Although you can still choose between Anderson and Udina to head the new council, only the former will reinstate your Spectre status in Mass Effect 2. If I had to make a Mass Effect Morality decision, I'd go: Paragon - Anderson Paragade (more Paragon) - Udina Renegon (more Renegade) - Anderson Renegade - Udina In personality, in ME1, Anderson is more of a Paragon while Udina is more of a Renegade. Additionally, Anderson (or Udina) have so little focus in Mass Effect 2 that even then the decision feels lackluster to most fans. After that, he leaves the position, meaning Udina is the human Councilor in Mass Effect 3 regardless of which choice was made in ME1. So as a last resort, he turns to Cerberus. Anderson vs Udina on the Council. Obviously Bioware decided your choice of councilor was wrong and Udina should be the councilor. Nevertheless, the show must go on. So as a last resort, he turns to Cerberus. Commander Shepard's induction into the Spectres is seen as the first step toward humanity gaining a seat on the Citadel Council, but this is a thorny issue as humans are still newcomers.Initially the Council is reluctant to bow to the pressure from Ambassador Udina, but proof of Saren Arterius' treachery, and Saren's vendetta against humans, forced their hand. Source: EA. He's a prick after all!But just for kicks and giggles; here ya go! The Council would step in if the geth attacked a turian colony! In Mass Effect, Commander Shepard can appoint either Ambassador Udina or Captain Anderson to be the human Councilor. You can choose between Udina, Anderson, or letting the council decide. One of the tie-in Mass Effect novels tells the story of Anderson's . Players are faced with a choice in Mass Effect when the Normandy is put in lockdown. By default, Cerberus became the only way to save Earth, so Udina took the option. Anderson offers to help by either breaking into an office or Citadel control. A new council is formed in their stead; diverse if your morality spectrum was Paragon-focused, human-only if Renegade. Mass Effect 3 Consequences: The Alliance fleet will be weaker War Assets, however, you will gain the Ascension as a War Asset as well. Genshin Impact; Apex Legends; Fortnite; Destiny; Among Us; Sunday, 16 May 2021 21:18 Mass Effect: Anderson or Udina for Council - What's the Best Choice? "Stand amongst the ashes of a trillion dead souls and ask the ghosts if honor matters." Boards. I just picked up a Hauppage HD PVR today, so I've decided to go through my videos and re-upload some of the more popular ones in HD, starting with this one. Now Udina knows how it feels to be Shepard. Udina is a snake but atleast he's humanity's snake and he knows his way around politics. Now in Mass Effect 3, Udina is the one who is isolated and is forced to fight the battle for Earth alone. So at the end of ME1, regardless of whether the old council lives or dies, you get to choose who the human councilor is: Anderson or Udina. By the events of Mass Effect 3, Captain Anderson will inevitably not be a member of the council anymore, being replaced by Ambassador Udina. I could already see the spittle flying out of that bastard's mouth as he . I bet the council had some good laughs running circles around Anderson for 2 years, poor guy. You again get to choose between Captain Anderson or Ambassador Udina to serve the Council. 2nd Best Mass Effect Decision: Save the Council or the Alliance Fleet. If you port this save into Mass Effect 2, the Council offers to reinstate your Spectre status, which . In Mass Effect 3, Udina will become humanity's representative on the Citadel Council even if you choose Anderson in Mass Effect 1. At the end of Mass Effect 1, Commander Shepard faces yet another tough choice: they need to decide who should be appointed to the Citidel Council, Anderson or Udina. Instead of Udina, Anderson knocks out a nearby turian who is guarding the controls.Much like with this first choice, there isn't any backlash to these actions as the council sees that it was for . But, again, this choice has little impact on Mass Effect 2's gameplay. If you had chosen Anderson to be the Councilor, it's mentioned in his codex entry that he transfers his office over to Udina as part of these events. Anderson will push to get you reinstated as a Spectre, regardless of your earlier choice regarding the Council, while Udina will oppose it - successfully, if he's sitting on . NPC dialogue in the Citadel in Mass . If you do save the Citadel Council and have a say, then almost everyone picked Anderson as humanity's ambassador. Mass Effect: Why Captain David Anderson Is the Best Choice for Human Councilor. The choice between Anderson and Udina is a big one in Mass Effect 1 because Shepard will need all the help they can get against the reapers. By Louis Kemner Published May 14, 2021 However, if the Council dies, and Udina is . He is the System's Alliance ambassador to the Citadel Council who is determined to ensure the advancement of human interests in the galaxy.